How to Take In Critical Feedback Without Personalizing It (Part 2)
Updated: Nov 14
New Role Now What? | Episode 8 | 30 min
Follow the podcast: Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Critical feedback can send you straight into fight or flight: racing heart, red face, and an urge to defend yourself. And sometimes it's not even harsh feedback. It's one small comment in an otherwise great review that your brain can't let go of.
In Part 2 of this feedback resilience series, I walk you through my four-step process for moving through critical or constructive feedback so you can take in what's useful without spiraling. If you haven't heard Part 1, start there for the framework this builds on.
Key takeaways
1. Wait 24 hours.
Feedback that feels negative registers as rejection, and your brain responds as if you're in danger. That's a bad state for processing information. Give yourself a day (or longer) before you respond or dig in, and let yourself feel what you feel. It's normal.
2. Strain it into a neutral sentence.
Sift out the tone, context, and your feelings about your supervisor and workplace, and reduce each piece of feedback to one simple, neutral sentence. "You need to be more resourceful" becomes "I'm being asked to try to find the answer myself." It helps to imagine your best friend gave you the feedback.
3. Check what you're making it mean.
Notice if you're turning the feedback into "I'm not capable," "I'm not valued" or "I won't succeed here." Write those meanings down and cross them out. They're almost always far bigger than the actual feedback.
4. Ask: Where are they right?
This is the hardest step and the most powerful. Look for any mindset issue underneath, like fear of mistakes or fear of being disliked, that the feedback might be pointing to. Start by assuming there's something true in it. If something truly doesn't fit the consistent feedback you've received, it's okay to drop it as an outlier.
A note for managers: You can help people take in feedback by saying it directly: "You're valued here, and I believe in your capability. Here's my feedback."
The reframe
"This feedback is information about my skills, not a verdict on my worth or my future."
Not sure if you're struggling or just new?
Want more support? Get the free coaching guide, How to Stop Feeling Judged and Insecure in Your New Role →, or book a free consultation.

Comments