top of page

Why Is My New Job So Hard? How to Handle Insecurity at Work

May 6, 2025
6 min read

Updated: Nov 14

New Role Now What? | Confidence Boost episode | 10 min

Follow the podcast: Apple Podcasts | Spotify

When you're struggling in a new role, it's easy to get stuck on one question: Why is this so hard for me? It seems to come easier to everyone around you, and the harder you search for the answer, the worse you feel.

In this Confidence Boost episode, I explain why that question keeps you spinning, why work magnifies the insecurities you've carried your whole life, and the simple, clear answer to give yourself so you can move through self-doubt without judging yourself for having it.

Key takeaways

1. The question has a judgment hidden in it. "Why is this so hard for me?" sounds rational, but underneath it is the belief that it shouldn't be hard, and that the struggle means something is wrong with you. Finding the "why" rarely undoes the feeling. The judgment is what keeps you stuck.

2. You're not broken, weak, or too sensitive. Struggling with insecurity at work doesn't mean you're fragile or not cut out for the role. It means you're a person doing a job that matters to you.

3. Workplaces are magnifying glasses. Work activates our deepest human needs: to impress, connect, be seen, and belong. On top of that, you're being paid to perform, so your brain links your performance to your income, your security, and your status. It overestimates the risk, which is why whatever insecurity you've carried through life ("I'm not smart enough," "people don't like me," "I'm not as dynamic as others") shows up louder at work.

4. Don't build an identity around it. The danger is letting a hard moment turn into a story about who you are: "I'm someone who just isn't confident." That narrative makes the struggle feel permanent.

The reframe

When your brain demands to know why this is so hard, give it a simple, calm answer:

"Workplaces magnify insecurities. This is normal. This is one of mine, and that's why it's coming up right now."

Then let it be there. Don't judge it, don't push against it, and don't indulge it. For many people, this alone puts the challenge back in proportion. You may still feel some discomfort, but you'll move through it.

If you stop fighting the feeling and find it's still seriously disrupting your work or well-being, that's useful information too. It may be time to slow down and get more support, whether from a coach, a therapist, or both.

Episode chapters

  • 0:00 Why does this feel so hard?

  • 2:00 You are not broken

  • 3:53 Workplaces magnify our insecurities

  • 6:10 Right-sizing your workplace challenges

  • 9:27 A simple answer to stop self-judgment

Not sure if you're struggling or just new?

Full transcript

(Lightly edited for readability.)

It's incredibly frustrating to feel like something is so difficult for us when it appears to be easier for the people around us. So let's dive in and answer this question: why does this feel so hard for me? And let's give your brain an answer that's going to stop the spinning, the self-judgment, and the feeling that you're broken in some way.

Hello, hello. Welcome back to another Confidence Boost episode. I'm really loving coming in here and giving you all something quick, short, and sweet, but to the point.

This week we're going to answer the question that so many of us have. When we're stuck feeling insecure, when we're in a challenge and a lot of self-doubt is coming up, I find that we (myself included) tend to get really stuck asking ourselves: Why is this so hard for me? Why am I struggling so much? Why can't I just feel confident?

The question itself seems really innocent and rational, and a lot of us want the answer because we think, if I find the answer, I'm going to stop feeling this way. The truth is, sometimes finding the answer doesn't actually undo the feeling. The feeling is rooted in fears and insecurities that sometimes need more time and attention to work through.

But what I want to focus on today is that the question "Why is this so hard for me?" often has a really deep judgment in it: that it shouldn't be hard, that I shouldn't be feeling this way, that this situation shouldn't be as challenging for me as it is. So I want to talk about what to do when that question comes up and what to say to it, so you don't get stuck spinning.

I'll use the example of being in a new job. Maybe you're not brand new anymore and there's a new challenge at work that's really hard, or giving feedback to your team is really hard for you. It could be anything that's bringing up insecurity and self-doubt, where you find yourself questioning your capabilities, second-guessing yourself, trying to prove yourself, and your brain starts asking: Why is this so hard for me?

The first thing I want to say is: you are not broken. You are not weak. You're not overly sensitive. You're not fragile because you're struggling with an insecurity in your job.

Work feels hard because workplaces are like magnifying glasses. You may have heard me talk about this in other episodes, but it's important to be reminded. The workplace brings up all of our human needs to impress, connect, be seen, and be validated. On top of that, you're being paid to perform. You're literally being handed money to perform, so your food, your water, your shelter, and your status are connected to all of this.

For a lot of people, work also brings up a deep sense of belonging, that very human desire to be part of the group. So you start to connect your performance, your mistakes, and your fear of failure to all of those things. What happens is the brain overblows the risk. It doesn't understand the nuances of your financial situation, that you have a support network outside of work, that you have a broader community, that you're safe and secure in many, many ways.

So these deeper instincts kick in, and they tap into our biggest insecurities. If your biggest insecurity throughout your life has been feeling like you're not smart enough, that will often get magnified at work. If it's that people don't like you, or that you aren't as dynamic or extroverted as other people, or you don't have enough charisma, whatever your big insecurity is, it tends to get extremely magnified at work, because of that connection to money, to being evaluated, to having our performance looked at.

So it's tempting to interpret this struggle as a sign that something is deeply wrong with you. The brain can get into a lot of drama: Why is it doing this? Why am I not confident? Why is this always a struggle for me? And it starts to connect the experience to something inherently wrong with you, something about who you are that's broken, and that starts to feel like part of your identity.

I always want to steer my clients away from starting some big narrative about themselves, like I'm a person who doesn't have confidence and gets insecure. We can get really stuck feeling connected to that as part of our identity and overblowing it, especially when it shows up at work, because things feel so heightened there.

So I want you to try answering the question with a simple, clear answer. When your brain asks, Why is this so hard for me? Why are my insecurities getting kicked up? Why am I having self-doubt? answer it with this: Workplaces magnify our insecurities. This is really normal. This is one of mine, and that's why it's being brought to the surface right now.

Give it a clear, calm answer and avoid indulging it or spinning in it. Let yourself be in a space that accepts that this insecurity is coming up. Don't judge it, don't push against it, don't indulge it. Just let it be.

For some of you, this will really ease what's happening. It will right-size it. You might have some discomfort, but you'll move past it. For others, once you stop pushing against it, you may realize this is becoming too disruptive to your work or your well-being, and you want to take it to your therapist, get support, slow down, and look into it more. But this first step is so important, and so many people miss it. Sometimes it's all we need to move past what's going on.

So today's quick boost is simply this: answer the question. I'm at work, and work naturally amplifies insecurities. This is normal. Be clear and direct with yourself when your brain demands to know why. Stop using it against yourself. Let yourself be in a challenge that's kicking up your insecurities without making yourself feel bad for having them.

Thank you for joining me for this Confidence Boost episode. If you're feeling stuck in self-doubt or frustration and it's interfering with your well-being or your daily life at work, head over to ErinMFoley.com. The link is in the show notes. I'll see you back here next week.

 
 
 

Comments


  • Instagram - Grey Circle
  • LinkedIn - Grey Circle
  • Facebook - Grey Circle

Copyright 2022-Erin Foley-All rights reserved

bottom of page