How to Take In Critical Feedback Without Personalizing It (Part 1)
Updated: Nov 14
New Role Now What? | Episode 7 | 27 min
Follow the podcast: Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Taking in critical feedback can feel like getting hit by a freight train. It's especially common to feel it in a new job, when you don't yet know what to expect, how you compare, or how your supervisor really sees you.
In Part 1 of this feedback resilience series, I explain what feedback resilience is, why chasing positive feedback actually makes you more fragile, and the first strategy for taking in feedback without getting defensive: separating your human value from your professional value.
Key takeaways
1. Feedback resilience is a superpower.
It means you can take in critical and constructive feedback without defensiveness, without over-personalizing it, and without getting stuck in shame, and then quickly see what's useful and apply it.
2. Positive feedback is a short-term fix.
When you're insecure, it's easy to get "thirsty for encouragement." But praise wears off like a drug, and the anxiety comes back. Trying to avoid negative feedback tells your brain you can't handle it. What actually calms you down is becoming open to all feedback.
3. Separate your human value from your professional value.
Your worth as a person is inherent. Your professional value is your skills (hard and soft) plus your knowledge base. You're paid for your skills and knowledge, not your worthiness. (I learned this concept from Stacey Boehman and apply it to the workplace.)
4. Your professional value changes, and that's normal.
A promotion or a move to a new industry can lower the value of some of your skills or knowledge in that setting, which just means there's a learning curve to close. Feedback is the fastest way to close it.
5. Opt in to feedback.
List your hard skills, soft skills and knowledge base. Then decide whether you want to grow your professional value, which often brings more money, choices and autonomy. If yes, commit to wanting feedback on all of it.
The reframe
"Feedback is about my skills, not my worth. I want it, because it helps me grow."
Not sure if you're struggling or just new?
Want more support? Get the free coaching guide, How to Stop Feeling Judged and Insecure in Your New Role →, or book a free consultation.

Comments